Excellent Creative Zen Is No iPod Killer

Written by Dave Jansen     21/10/2009 | 06:42 | Category name i.e.MP3 PLAYERS

Creative have had a hard slog in the media player market. They have consistently produced reasonable players but have had a hard time taking any market share. The reason is comes down to brand positioning and innovation, both of which they sorely lack. The new Zen XFi2 continues their trend of players that produce excellent sound and a wide range of features. The design is much more streamlined and attractive than previous players but there is no real innovation in the product and as such, they will undoubtedly join the background noise of the MP3 market dominated by the Apple iPod.

We tested the XFi2 and were impressed with its audio performance.  It has EQ settings, which work quite well but without them it still sounds excellent.  The XFi sound processing needs to be turned on and can be adjusted to boost the music and make it feel more robust.  However, while it did make it sound better at mid volume, when the player reached the higher end of its volume range, having the XFi features switched on created some distortion and hiss.  The Zen is capable of extremely loud volume though and most normal people that respect their eardrums probably won't sit on the highest setting very often.  If you do listen to it at that volume, we recommend you turn the Xfi features off.

Like previous Zen players, there are quite a lot of features crammed into one tiny package.  The player can display videos and images in addition to audio files.  The video formats supported are Windows Media 9, MPEG4, Divx and XViD.  The audio codecs include MP3, WMA (DRM9), WAV (IMA-ADPCM) Audible4, AAC and FLAC..  It is rare to find an MP3 player that will support lossless formats like FLAC, which is likely to make audiophiles quite happy.  The image formats are limited to JPG and BMP although the bundled software will convert TIFF, GIF and PNG files.  There is no RAW support though.  The player also has an FM radio and voice recorder feature which works quite well. The microphone picked up a little background noise when recording but it wasn't too bad.

The interface is similar to previous Zen players but has had a few minor tweaks that are vast improvements.  However, like previous models, it is a little cumbersome to use and will take some getting used to.  In a market dominated by the iPod, the way to a customers heart is a slick and easy to use interface and in that regard, the Zen falls down.  The biggest issue with the interface is that it isn't as responsive as it needs to be.  The touch screen picks up the user interaction easily enough but the operating system is a little sluggish at times diminishing the enjoyment of the player.  For example, scrolling through lists quickly is difficult as the list tends to scroll too fast or too slow.  You are constantly having to go back through as you miss what you are after.  Another example is the way you unlock the device which Involves dragging an icon off screen to unlock.  This is slow to move and often has to be done more than once to be effective.  It seems like a minor issue but it is things like this that Apple does well and what customers respond to.

 

The design is very attractive with very few buttons.  The device is dominated by the 3inch TFT touch screen.  The resolution of the screen is only 400x240 pixels which makes the icons lose some fidelity and appear a little pixelated at times.  Also the screen isn't bright enough and gets drowned out in sunlight.  With many players adopting LED or OLED screens, a TFT screen is a little outdated.

The device used mini USB to connect to a PC which also acts as its charger via trickle charging.  It also uses the same port to facilitate its TV out functionality but the required cable is not included in the sales package.  The internal storage comes in 8GB, 16GB and 32GB variants but it also has a MicroSD slot so the storage possibilities are unlimited.

The supplied headphones are very impressive too.  The Zen comes with Creative EP-630 in-ear earphones which sound great.  Being in-ear, they cut out quite a bit of background noise. They aren't quite as effective at noise cancelling as other headphones on the market but considering you get them as part of the sales package, we were highly impressed with their performance.
The Zen XFi2 has it problems but on the whole it is an impressive little player.  Audiophile will love the file support and sound quality and even fashionistas will enjoy its aesthetic. It doesn't have the chops to put a dent in the media player market though but if you are looking for an alternative to an iPod, it is an excellent choice.

Pricing:

8GB    $154.50
16GB $199.95
32GB $272.68

Top Ranked Reviews

  • Review: LG G Pad 10.1 Tablet Has Nifty Features But Is Mid-Range

    Review: LG G Pad 10.1 Tablet Has Nifty Features But Is Mid-Range

    LG's latest tablet, the G Pad 10.1, delivers a range of new features in a mid-range package that brings a solid brand name and experience to those willing to spend a little more than rock bottom prices for a much better tablet experience.
    Product Rating 3

  • Review: HTC's One Mini 2, A Great Android Smartphone

    Review: HTC's One Mini 2, A Great Android Smartphone

    With smartphones going extra big, it's great to see a powerful, premium-styled smartphone in a smaller configuration from a top brand name that's smooth and comfortable in your hand.
    Product Rating 4

  • Review: Marley's Liberate XLBT Bluetooth Headset

    Review: Marley's Liberate XLBT Bluetooth Headset

    The House of Marley has produced a quality on-ear Bluetooth headset with controls with included optional connection cord, taking the best of the wired Liberate XL headset and making it better!
    Product Rating 4

  • Review: Marley Liberate BT Bluetooth Speaker With Mic

    Review: Marley Liberate BT Bluetooth Speaker With Mic

    A new portable Bluetooth speaker with 8 hours of rechargeable battery life, stylish "industrial" design, Bob Marley branding and a hidden mic for handsfree calls has arrived to stir things up a bit.
    Product Rating 4

  • Review: Fitbit Flex Wearable Fitness Tracker

    Review: Fitbit Flex Wearable Fitness Tracker

    Testing Fitbit's wrist-band wearable fitness tracker over the past couple of weeks has been an interesting experiment that sees me wanting to continue the tracking and reaching the daily 10,000 steps goal - but I wish it also told the time.
    Product Rating 4

Pros & Cons

Pros:

Excellent sound quality, Wide volume range, FLAC support, Heaps of features, Xfi processing, Good price

Cons:

Sluggish Interface, Low resolution screen, TFT screen is a little outdated.