REVIEW: Kodak PlaySport Takes Sexy Shots And A Beating

Written by James Morris     25/05/2011 | 04:25 | Category name i.e.DIGITAL PHOTOGRAPHY

Can rivals get any more rugged that Kodak's Playsport Zx5? It's dustproof, waterproof and shockproof but how will it stand up to being treated rough?


Key Features

    * 1/3.2in CMOS sensor with 5Mpixels
    * 4x digital zoom
    * 2in LCD
    * SDHC memory card slot
    * Waterproof to 3m, dustproof, survives drop of 1.5m

With the Playsport Zx5, Kodak has built on the excellent Zx3, and added standards-compliant dust and shock proofing. The result is a camcorder ready for a wider range of outdoor activities. The specifications and performance are otherwise very similar. So although the new model is a little more expensive, making it slightly worse value overall, it's the better choice if you want a cheap pocket camcorder able to resist the elements and a bit of rough treatment.

Kodak brought waterproof Full HD video shooting to a new low price with its Playsport Zx3. But whilst this model looked pretty rugged, Kodak gave no guarantee of its ability to withstand rough treatment. Enter the Zx5; rated dustproof and shockproof, as well as waterproof.

The dust rating complies with IEC 60529 IP6X, and shock proofing with MIL-STD-810F, meaning that the Zx5 can withstand a fall from a height of 1.5m. The waterproofing specification hasn't changed, with Kodak still quoting a maximum depth of 3m, although this is now stated as being compliant with the IEC 60529 IPX8 standard.

Inside, the Zx5 has a slightly different specification to the earlier version. Both incorporate 5MPixel sensors, but the Zx5's CMOS one is a slightly smaller 1/3.2 inch version, where the Zx3's is 1/2.5 inches. This does have implications for low light sensitivity, and Kodak doesn't mention any back-side illumination technology to compensate. The same range of recording modes are on offer. The top option is 1080p Full HD captured at 30 frames/sec, but you can also grab 720p at 30 or 60 frames/sec, and WVGA at 30 frames/sec. The latter is a widescreen version of VGA, with a resolution of 848 x 480 pixels. You can take still images at 5.3Mpixels, too.
The Zx5 does come with 128MB of memory on board, but the lion's share of this is already earmarked for the built-in software (of which more later), leaving a miserly 20MB for video - enough merely to check the camcorder is working. So you will need to call on the SD memory card slot. This only supports SDHC, not the latest SDXC format. So capacity maxes out at 32GB. This will be enough for around 13 hours of footage at the top 1080p quality setting.
So what of the much-vaunted toughness? The device is encased in soft-touch, mildly rubberised plastic. There are two lockable doors covering the ports and memory slot respectively. Rubber seals inside cover the openings themselves, and the doors are held in place by switches which lock into place. These don't feel quite as secure as Panasonic's toughened camcorders, such as the Panasonic SDR-SW20, but our experiments with trying to knock these open 'accidentally' proved ineffective. A direct blow on the switch might just trip it, but this would be a rather unlucky situation.

We also dropped the device in water and from heights of over a metre onto a variety of surfaces. Hard, rough floors did leave the occasional scuff mark on the finish of the device, but the waterproofing doors remained closed and there were no signs of the chassis fracturing. Overall, whilst we wouldn't recommend use during extreme sports, the Zx5 will certainly withstand most non-extreme leisure activities. However, it's also worth noting that in the move to greater toughness, the battery is no longer removable, unlike the Zx3, so you would probably have to buy a new camcorder if this becomes dysfunctional out of warranty.
As with most pocket Internet camcorders, the Zx5 isn't exactly brimming with features. The zoom is just 4x and digital, so there is a noticeable drop in quality when it's engaged. A small range of digital effects are available, including High Saturation, '70s Film, Black and White, and Sepia. An underwater correction filter is included, which compensates for the colour shift caused by shooting through water. The Zx5 does have image stabilisation, too, but it's digital and only marginally effective. Still worth having, but technological development has focused on this area quite a bit in recent premium camcorders, and there's a wider gulf between these and budget models now.

Amazingly, the Zx5 does have a microphone gain control so you can compensate for very loud or quiet audio. You can configure the anti-glare system, and LCD brightness, which mildly improves viewing angles in direct sunlight. There is also, allegedly, face-detection, although with the fixed lens this will only affect exposure, and we didn't see any signs of it in operation during testing anyway. There's a macro mode hidden in the menu system, too, which allows focusing down to 7cm (10cm underwater) instead of the 10cm (13cm underwater) in normal mode. You don't get any backlight compensation option, though, which would have been handy for manually counteracting the effects of shooting something against a very bright background, such as a sunny sky or snow.
Although the Zx5 has a slightly smaller sensor than the Zx3, video quality isn't noticeably different. In Full HD mode, there's plenty of detail, but white balance is a little off, with a mildly yellow tinge to footage shot in bright sunlight. The results are still good for a camcorder in this class, however, comparing well to similarly priced Flip models. Low-light performance is decent, too. The image is a little dark, but there's not much sign of noise, and there's a good level of detail. Sharpness is some way behind more expensive pocket Internet models such as Sony's Bloggie Touch MHS-TS20K, but this is again a commendable performance.
Although the Zx5 is still essentially a pocket Internet model, the constraints of waterproofing have prevented the usual addition of a full-sized USB plug. So you will need to bring the cable with you to connect the camcorder to a computer. When you do, there are two apps available. The Share button on the camera lets you choose to upload to Facebook, Flickr, YouTube, via email and (in the case of still images) your Kodak PULSE Display gallery. The uploads then proceed automatically when you connect the camcorder to your computer. You can also tag your uploads on Twitter, Orkut, Yandex and KAIXIN001, although the actual choices depend on the region in which you bought the camcorder.

If you want to edit your clips prior to upload, there's also a special Kodak version of Arcsoft's Media Impression, which installs automatically when you connect the device to a PC. This provides facilities to trim your clips; add a voice-over, pictures and music; grab stills from video, and then upload to your favourite sharing site. Both apps, as with so many pocket Internet camcorders, are PC only, with no Mac support. However, there's also a limited amount of on-camera footage editing available. You can trim the in and out points of clips, and grab a still frame as a separate photo.

Verdict

The Kodak Playsport Zx3 was already great value for a waterproof pocket Internet camcorder. The Zx5 is more expensive than the current price for the Zx3, and although it doesn't add much in the way of extra features, the improved shock rating makes it even more dependable for outdoor activities. The Zx5 can't quite compete with its predecessor's low price, with the Zx5 going for $249, but we'd still recommend it if you want a camcorder you can take with you anywhere, come rain, shine or a rough ride.
To read the original review, click here

Top Ranked Reviews

  • Review: LG G Pad 10.1 Tablet Has Nifty Features But Is Mid-Range

    Review: LG G Pad 10.1 Tablet Has Nifty Features But Is Mid-Range

    LG's latest tablet, the G Pad 10.1, delivers a range of new features in a mid-range package that brings a solid brand name and experience to those willing to spend a little more than rock bottom prices for a much better tablet experience.
    Product Rating 3

  • Review: HTC's One Mini 2, A Great Android Smartphone

    Review: HTC's One Mini 2, A Great Android Smartphone

    With smartphones going extra big, it's great to see a powerful, premium-styled smartphone in a smaller configuration from a top brand name that's smooth and comfortable in your hand.
    Product Rating 4

  • Review: Marley's Liberate XLBT Bluetooth Headset

    Review: Marley's Liberate XLBT Bluetooth Headset

    The House of Marley has produced a quality on-ear Bluetooth headset with controls with included optional connection cord, taking the best of the wired Liberate XL headset and making it better!
    Product Rating 4

  • Review: Marley Liberate BT Bluetooth Speaker With Mic

    Review: Marley Liberate BT Bluetooth Speaker With Mic

    A new portable Bluetooth speaker with 8 hours of rechargeable battery life, stylish "industrial" design, Bob Marley branding and a hidden mic for handsfree calls has arrived to stir things up a bit.
    Product Rating 4

  • Review: Fitbit Flex Wearable Fitness Tracker

    Review: Fitbit Flex Wearable Fitness Tracker

    Testing Fitbit's wrist-band wearable fitness tracker over the past couple of weeks has been an interesting experiment that sees me wanting to continue the tracking and reaching the daily 10,000 steps goal - but I wish it also told the time.
    Product Rating 4

Pros & Cons

Pros:

Waterproof to 3m; Withstands drop from 1.5m; Full HD shooting

Cons:

No built-in memory; Fixed battery; No backlight compensation setting